Bali property deals can look simple until paperwork is tested by a dispute, an inspection, or a tax review. Many expats learn too late that what they “bought” is only a private promise.
When enforcement tightens, the same gaps repeat: nominee freehold schemes, unclear titles, skipped PPAT steps, and rentals run without the right permits or reporting. The downside can be asset loss, fines, or serious legal exposure.
This guide reduces Bali property investment risks for expats using official rules as a checklist—starting with PP 18/2021 on land rights and ending with an enforceable deal file.
Table of Contents
- Why expats lose money in Bali property
- Legal ownership routes foreigners can use
- Nominee schemes: why they fail and how to spot them
- PT PMA for rentals: compliance duties you must maintain
- Real Story: a nominee deal stopped in Berawa, Canggu
- Due diligence controls before deposits and signing
- Taxes, fees, and ROI traps expats underestimate
- Immigration and operational compliance for rentals
- FAQ's about Bali property investment risk prevention
Why expats lose money in Bali property
Losses usually come from three avoidable failures. First is structure: control is bought through a private promise instead of a recognized right, so the “owner on paper” can still decide your fate.
Second is weak verification. Screenshots replace land office checks, zoning is assumed, and access/encumbrances are ignored—then permits or resale get blocked.
Third is informal operations. A villa can exist physically but still be unfit for commercial rentals, making income fragile when inspections or complaints happen.
Legal ownership routes foreigners can use
Foreigners cannot hold Hak Milik (freehold) in their own name. Safer routes are typically: Hak Pakai for residence use (eligibility depends on stay status and use), HGB held via PT PMA for business use, or a properly notarized and registered long-term leasehold.
Apartments/strata can be possible under the relevant framework, but underlying land rights remain limited (Hak Pakai/HGB) and time-bound. Treat broad “everyone qualifies” claims as Not confirmed until checked against your status and the property classification.
Nominee schemes: why they fail and how to spot them
Nominee deals put Hak Milik in an Indonesian name “for” the foreign buyer with side agreements to mimic ownership. Multiple sources describe these structures as illegal and unenforceable because they bypass nationality restrictions.
In practice, the nominee is the owner. If they sell, mortgage, divorce, die, or refuse to cooperate, your control can disappear and the dispute becomes expensive.
Walk away when you see: deposit pressure, refusal of independent checks, “PPAT later,” “standard nominee packages,” or promises you can “convert to your name later.”
PT PMA for rentals: compliance duties you must maintain
PT PMA can support commercial control and villa operations, but it adds obligations. Your KBLI and licensing path must match what the villa actually does, and ongoing reporting/renewals must be maintained.
Common failures include missing investment reporting (LKPM where applicable), letting licenses lapse, or operating tourism-style rentals under the wrong approvals—each can trigger sanctions up to license restrictions or revocation.
If you see capital-threshold numbers online, treat them as Not confirmed unless verified against the latest official text that applies to your case.
Real Story: a nominee deal stopped in Berawa, Canggu
Liam, a UK expat, was offered a “safe freehold via nominee” villa in Berawa with a discount if he wired a deposit within 48 hours. The agent said PPAT steps could be handled later.
His lawyer asked for certificate verification, encumbrance checks, documented access, and a clear legal route for the intended rental use. The seller could not prove clean control and the nominee rejected restrictions on sale or mortgage.
Outcome: Liam walked away and took a registered long-term leasehold with staged payments tied to verified documents—protecting capital and avoiding a likely dispute.
Due diligence controls before deposits and signing
Use a licensed PPAT and demand a clear deed/registration trail. “Under-the-table” transfers are a red flag because they are hard to defend in court.
Verify: seller authority, title type, mortgages/disputes, and documented access/right-of-way. Then verify zoning and permit history (IMB for older builds; the current framework may involve PBG and post-build certificates depending on the project). If it cannot be proven, mark it Not confirmed and pause.
For residence-linked eligibility and foreign rights in plain language, see: Hukumonline guidance.
Taxes, fees, and ROI traps expats underestimate
Budget like an operator, not a tourist. Plan for transfer taxes, PPAT/notary fees, and recurring taxes, then decide who pays what in writing before signing.
BPHTB is often described as 5% of taxable acquisition value (after local non-taxable thresholds). Sellers are commonly described as paying final income tax on transfers (often cited as 2.5% of declared price). Because rates/thresholds vary by region and updates, treat exact numbers as Not confirmed until verified for your local office and documents.
Stress-test rental returns at lower occupancy and include maintenance cycles, utilities, staffing, insurance, platform fees, and compliance costs.
Immigration and operational compliance for rentals
Property ownership does not grant the right to stay or work. Some regimes may link foreign use rights to valid residence status, and managing a business can require visa/role alignment with what you actually do on the ground.
For short-term rentals, treat the villa as a regulated accommodation business: correct entity, correct license route, guest reporting where required, and nuisance controls for noise, waste, and parking. One complaint can become an inspection that pauses income.
To keep Bali property investment risks for expats low long-term, build a compliance system: document folders, renewal dates, and clean records from day one.
FAQ's about Bali property investment risk prevention
-
Can I legally buy a freehold (Hak Milik) in my personal name?
No. Foreign individuals cannot hold Hak Milik directly.
-
Are nominee agreements safe if drafted by a notary?
Many sources describe nominee structures as illegal and unenforceable, so they remain high risk.
-
Is leasehold secure for expats?
It can be, if properly drafted, notarized, and registered with enforceable renewal and dispute terms.
-
When does PT PMA make sense for villas?
When the asset is used commercially, you will maintain corporate, licensing, and reporting duties.
-
What should I verify before paying a deposit?
Title type, seller authority, encumbrances/disputes, documented access, zoning, and permit history.
